Is Buy Sell Agreement Life Insurance the Safest Way to Protect Your Business in 2026?
If you are a business owner, you have probably asked yourself a hard question: “What happens to this company—and to my family—if I die or my partner dies first?”
A buy sell agreement life insurance strategy is supposed to answer that. It can turn a tragic, stressful moment into a clear plan: your partner keeps the business, your family gets a fair buyout, and the company keeps moving forward.
But 2026 is different from past years. Supreme Court rulings, such as the Connelly decision, have changed how life insurance inside some buy-sell agreements is treated for estate tax purposes. In certain cases, corporate-owned policies can actually increase the taxable value of an owner’s estate if the agreement is not structured correctly.
So now the questions get sharper:
- “Should my company own the policies, or should the partners own them on each other?”
- “Will our current documents hold up if the IRS looks closely?”
- “Am I sure my family will really get the value of my share—after taxes?”
In this updated 2026 guide, we will walk through what a buy-sell agreement is, how buy sell agreement life insurance funding works, the difference between cross-purchase and entity (stock-redemption) plans, how the new court rulings affect tax outcomes, and simple steps to review your current plan with your advisors before it is tested in real life.
What Is a Buy-Sell Agreement and How Does Life Insurance Fit In?
At its core, a buy-sell agreement is a written promise between business co-owners about what will happen to an ownership stake when someone dies, becomes disabled, retires, or has to leave the business. Think of it as a “business will” that decides who can buy the departing owner’s interest, when, and at what price.
When you add life insurance, the agreement becomes buy sell agreement life insurance. The policy creates the cash needed to buy out the deceased owner’s share quickly, so the surviving owners keep control of the company and the deceased owner’s family receives a fair payment instead of an illiquid minority stake they may not want.
Without this funding, your buy-sell agreement might look good on paper but fail in real life because nobody has the money to complete the buyout.
Visual overview of how a properly funded buy-sell agreement works: death of an owner → insurance payout → family buyout → updated ownership.
How Do Buy-Sell Agreements Actually Work Day to Day?
It is easy to get lost in legal language, so it helps to picture the buy-sell agreement as a set of “if-then” rules. If something major happens to an owner, then the agreement says exactly what must happen next—who buys, who sells, and how much gets paid.
Typical triggering events include death, permanent disability, retirement, divorce, bankruptcy, or a forced sale. When one of these events occurs, the agreement tells the remaining owners or the company to purchase the departing owner’s shares according to a formula or valuation method everyone accepted in advance. That valuation might be based on an appraisal, a multiple of earnings, or a fixed value that is updated regularly.
Once the value is known, the funding mechanism matters. If you have a solid buy sell agreement life insurance plan, the policy proceeds provide the cash to complete the buyout quickly rather than forcing the company or remaining partners to borrow or drain operating capital. For many closely held businesses, this is the difference between a controlled transition and a financial crisis.
This is where strong planning connects to guides like life insurance for small business owners and business succession planning with life insurance, which zoom out to the owner’s full wealth picture.
Why Is a Buy Sell Agreement Life Insurance Strategy So Important in 2026?
In a perfect world, your partners would get along with your spouse and children, and everyone would agree on what your ownership interest is worth. In reality, grief, money, and control rarely mix well. If there is no clear agreement and no funding plan, your family may suddenly become your partner’s new co-owner—or end up forced to sell for pennies on the dollar.
A well-crafted buy-sell agreement funded by life insurance addresses these problems in advance. It spells out the value, the terms, and the timeline. It also ensures cash will be there when needed so the business can continue without raiding savings or scrambling for loans.
However, 2026 brings a new wrinkle. Recent court decisions, including the Connelly case, have made it clear that in some entity-owned (stock-redemption) arrangements, life insurance proceeds may increase the value of the company—and therefore the deceased owner’s estate—for estate tax purposes. That means a strategy that once looked tax-efficient might now create unexpected estate tax exposure if not reviewed and updated.
For that reason, your buy sell agreement life insurance plan is not a “set it and forget it” document. It needs to be revisited when laws, valuations, or ownership structures change.
Cross-Purchase vs Entity (Stock-Redemption)
Which Funding Method Makes Sense Now?
When you hear people talk about buy-sell agreements, you will almost always hear two terms: cross-purchase and entity (or stock-redemption). Both can use life insurance to fund the buyout, but they work differently and now carry different tax implications.
In a cross-purchase agreement, each owner buys and owns a life insurance policy on every other owner. When one owner dies, the surviving owners receive the tax-free death benefit personally and use it to buy the deceased owner’s shares directly from their estate. The company’s balance sheet does not show the policy as an asset, which can help avoid the valuation issues highlighted in Connelly.
In an entity (stock-redemption) agreement, the company itself owns and is the beneficiary of life insurance policies on each owner. When an owner dies, the company uses the proceeds to redeem the deceased owner’s shares. This approach is simpler when there are many owners, but the Supreme Court has now clarified that, in some cases, those insurance proceeds still count as assets of the company for estate tax valuation—even when they are earmarked to buy the shares.
Some advanced strategies blend these ideas, using cross-purchase structures, <u>corporate owned life insurance (COLI)</u>, or even an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT) to hold policies and reduce estate tax exposure for large, closely held businesses. This is also where concepts overlap with key person life insurance, which protects against the loss of a key executive rather than an owner’s buyout.
How Much Life Insurance Do You Need to Fund a Buy-Sell Agreement?
Deciding on coverage amounts for a buy sell agreement life insurance plan starts with one basic question: “What is my share of the business actually worth today?” That sounds simple, but it requires an honest valuation process and documentation everyone can accept.
Typically, the amount of life insurance for each owner should match the value of that owner’s equity interest, considering any agreed-upon valuation formula in the buy-sell agreement. For example, if a company is worth $3 million and there are three equal owners, each owner might have $1 million of coverage allocated to their share. As the business grows, policies may need to be increased or replaced to keep pace with the higher value.
Of course, life does not always match the spreadsheet. If the insurance is less than the share value when someone dies, the agreement should say who covers the shortfall and on what terms, such as installment payments or partial financed buyouts. Conversely, if the insurance is more than the share value, the document should state who receives the excess: the company, the remaining owners, or the deceased owner’s estate.
These mechanics are where a strong agreement separates itself from something downloaded quickly from the internet. Coordinating the valuation, the coverage, and the funding method is essential to avoid confusion later.
-
Lock in coverage for buy-sell, key person, or collateral needs.
-
Compare real rates instead of “ballpark” advertising offers.
-
Work directly with a licensed expert—no call-center scripts.
Real-World Examples
How Buy Sell Agreement Life Insurance Works When Things Go Wrong
Examples make these concepts real. The original article’s ABC Company stories are a perfect way to see what is at stake.
First, imagine three equal partners—Tom, John, and Mike—who had their business valued at $1.5 million. Each owns 33.3%, and each carries a $500,000 life insurance policy tied to a cross-purchase buy-sell agreement. When John is tragically killed by a drunk driver, his family is understandably focused on grief, not corporate governance. Because the buy-sell agreement is funded correctly, the insurance company pays $500,000 to John’s family as the buyout price for his shares. Tom and Mike now own 50% each, and the company never had to scramble for cash.
Now change the facts slightly. John survives the accident but is permanently disabled and cannot perform his role. In that case, a disability buy-out policy designed alongside the life insurance buy-sell provides the funds to purchase John’s shares based on the agreement’s terms. Tom and Mike again end up with 50% each, while John receives fair compensation without being forced to remain an inactive owner.
These stories highlight why many business owners pair buy sell agreement life insurance with disability insurance for business owners: death is not the only event that can force a transition.
2026 Tax Warning
What the Connelly Case Means for Entity-Owned Life Insurance
The Connelly case has become a wake-up call for anyone using life insurance to fund an entity-owned buy-sell agreement. At a high level, the Supreme Court held that when a corporation owns life insurance to redeem a shareholder’s stock at death, the policy proceeds may still be counted as an asset in valuing the company for estate tax purposes—even if they are used immediately to buy back shares.
Why does this matter? It means the deceased owner’s estate might be valued based on a company balance sheet including the insurance proceeds but without an offsetting liability for the redemption obligation. In plain English, the policy that was supposed to fund the buyout can end up inflating the taxable estate.
What does this mean?
This does not mean entity-owned buy-sell planning is dead, but it does mean 2026 is the year to sit down with your tax advisor, attorney, and independent insurance professional to ask:
- “Is our current structure a cross-purchase, entity, or hybrid?”
- “If the company owns the policies, how will that look under the Connelly reasoning?”
- “Should we update our documents, move policies, or use a trust structure to reduce risk?”
Ignoring these questions could leave your family facing an unexpected estate tax bill at the worst possible time.
Step-by-Step: How to Set Up or Review a Buy Sell Agreement Funded by Life Insurance
Setting up a buy sell agreement life insurance strategy should not feel mysterious. It is a process with clear steps, and you can walk through them one at a time with the right team.
Here is a simple framework you can use to create a new agreement or review an existing one for 2026:
- Build Your Advisory Team
Before you pick coverage, bring in your business attorney, tax advisor/CPA, and an independent life insurance specialist. Each sees different risks and opportunities. - Clarify Ownership and Trigger Events
Confirm who the owners are, what percentage each owns, and exactly which events should trigger a buyout (death, disability, retirement, divorce, etc.). - Choose the Structure: Cross-Purchase, Entity, or Hybrid
Discuss whether a cross-purchase plan, entity (stock-redemption) plan, or hybrid approach best fits your ownership group, while taking Connelly-style tax issues into account. - Value the Business and Set Coverage Amounts
Use a valuation method that everyone agrees is fair. Match coverage amounts to each owner’s share, and plan for periodic reviews as the business grows. - Design the Life and Disability Policies
Decide on term vs permanent coverage, riders, and disability buy-out coverage if appropriate. Coordinate ownership and beneficiary designations with the chosen structure. - Draft and Sign the Buy-Sell Agreement
Work with your attorney to ensure the agreement clearly states who buys, who sells, how valuation works, and how shortfalls or excess insurance proceeds are handled. - Review Regularly—Especially After 2026 Changes
Revisit your plan after major tax law changes, ownership changes, or large jumps in business value. A quick review every few years can prevent costly surprises later.
-
1. We have a written buy-sell agreement signed by all owners.
-
2. Our agreement clearly defines how ownership transfers if an owner dies.
-
3. Life insurance is already in place to fully fund the buyout amount.
-
4. Policy ownership and beneficiaries match what the agreement requires.
-
5. We have reviewed our business value and coverage amounts within the last 24 months.
-
6. Our plan covers disability or early exit, not just death.
-
7. Each owner’s family understands how they will be bought out if something happens.
-
8. Our accountant and advisor have reviewed tax and cash-flow implications.
Related Articles
FAQs About Buy Sell Agreement Life Insurance in 2026
In most cases, premiums paid for buy sell agreement life insurance are not income-tax deductible for the business or owners. The trade-off is that death benefits are generally received income tax-free, though recent rulings can affect estate tax outcomes, so always confirm with your tax advisor.
Policy ownership depends on the structure. In a cross-purchase plan, each owner typically owns policies on the other owners. In an entity plan, the company owns policies on all owners. In 2026, many advisors are revisiting entity-owned designs because of Connelly’s estate tax implications.
Yes. Many agreements include disability and retirement triggers, and some use disability buy-out policies alongside life insurance. That way, an owner who cannot work—or who chooses to exit—can be bought out under clear terms instead of staying stuck in limbo.
If the buy sell agreement life insurance payout is less than the value of the departing owner’s share, the agreement should explain how to handle the gap—such as installment payments, financing, or partial redemptions—so the deal can still close fairly.
Even small businesses can benefit from a basic agreement. If your company has at least two owners and meaningful value, a simple, well-funded buy-sell can prevent disputes, protect families, and keep the doors open after an unexpected loss.
Final Thoughts
Is Your Buy Sell Agreement Life Insurance Strategy Really Ready?
At the end of the day, this is not just about documents and policies. It is about what actually happens to your life’s work, your partners, and your family if something happens to you.
If your agreement is old, underfunded, or still structured as a simple entity-owned redemption without considering the 2026 tax landscape, you may feel like you have done the responsible thing—while still leaving a hidden problem behind. That is exactly what recent court cases have exposed.
So pause and ask yourself:
- “If my partner died tomorrow, do we know exactly how the buyout would be paid—and would the IRS see it the same way we do?”
- “If I am the one who dies first, will my family receive the full value of my share, or will tax surprises eat into what they inherit?”
If you cannot answer those questions confidently, it is time to review your buy sell agreement life insurance strategy with your legal, tax, and independent insurance team. A few hours of planning now can prevent years of stress later—and may save your family from a painful, avoidable fight.
More Life Insurance Resources
